29 people locked in their top picks for this topic in RankWithFriends. Here's what the crowd actually chose.
Top score that day: 89/100
“Sunscreen, a fire starting kit, and fishing gear? You're practically a survivalist! While I appreciate the practicality of your picks, I can’t help but feel like you’re missing the fun of the desert island. Where's the hammock or the coconut drinks? Let’s just say your desert island is starting to sound more like a survival seminar than a vacation!”